Where to Stay on Eleuthera Bahamas

Eleuthera Bahamas is known for its pink sand beaches, turquoise ocean, and secluded snorkeling spots. It is a small outer island of the Bahamas, just a short flight from Nassau. What might surprise some visitors is the lack of resorts and restaurants on the island. If you are looking to truly get away from it all Eleuthera, Bahamas is a fantastic place for a vacation.Eleuthera Bahamas

Where to Stay

We chose to rent a two-bedroom Homeaway property in Governors Harbour with a private pool. Located in the center of Eleuthera Island, this stunning villa was surprisingly reasonable. Our average nightly rate for four people was just $392/night. We would never be able to afford to stay in a two-bedroom hotel suite of this size or caliber. This home has a beautiful living space, well-appointed kitchen, lots of outdoor living space and a washer and dryer. Our family had plenty of space to spread out. Our hosts Kathy and Bob were so warm and welcoming. On the first evening, Kathy even made us dinner which was a wonderful surprise after flying all day. Throughout our stay brought us fresh vegetables from her garden.Bahamas House Rental

Where to Eat

We prepared many of our meals at home. There are no large grocery stores on the island, you will need to gather your food from different markets. In Governors Harbor there are two small grocery stores, however, the biggest and best one is in Rock Sound. They even carry a few gluten-free products. Fair warning, everything costs almost double what it does in the United States. A half gallon of milk is $7.50! For fresh produce check out the wonderful farmer’s market on the southern end of the island. Another option for visitors traveling to Eleuthera is to bring dry goods and even frozen meat with them.

Eleuthera BahamasMost days you will find the local fisherman sharing the day’s catch on a stand right in the middle of town.  This is by far the best source for the fresh fish and lobster. They will filet your grouper or butterfly a lobster tail. Prices are very reasonable. I paid $10 for two of the tastiest lobster tails I have ever had.

Fresh Fish BahamasWhen our 15-year-old son wanted to learn to Scuba dive, we thought Eleuthera would be a great place to do it. We were right. The water is crystal clear and very calm. We spent a day with Al at Ocean Fox in Davis Harbor on the southern tip of the island. We highly recommend him for first-timers.

Snorkeling in the BahamasMost days though we spent exploring the uncrowded beaches of the island of Eleuthera. Often we were the only ones there. Just the way we like it!

Eleuthera BahamasTop 10 Tips for First Time Eleuthera Bahamas Visitors

  • Cash is King – Not a lot of places accept credit cards. There are ATMs on the island, but the surcharge is $3 plus your foreign transaction fee.
  • Tippy’s – You likely aren’t coming to Eleuthera for the cuisine. But if you are looking for a great meal be sure to make a reservation at Tippy’s one night.
  • Island Farm– Located in Palmetto Point.  Great place to find organic produce, freshly baked bread, cheese, salsa, and jams.
  • Banks Road Deli – This deli is on the road to Tippy’s. Here you can buy sliced deli meats, cheese, pasta, and sauces. Additionally, they also have fresh croissants and baguettes early in the day.
  • Bugs – They are vicious. There are no-see-ums and mosquitoes. Bring bug spray and/or sunscreen with bug spray in it.
  • Bottled Water – We had a 5-gallon water dispenser in our house. I should have brought refillable water bottles from home to take to the beach with us.
  • Car Rental – You will need one and it is very expensive! Between $55-65/day, plus pick up fees, etc. You won’t find a Hertz or Avis on the island. Your property agent can suggest where to rent cars.
  • Beaches – Get out and discover as many beaches as you can. As cell service is unreliable, be sure to print the directions and take a map with you. We loved French Leaves (AKA Club Med) and Twin Cove.
  • Harbour Island – Worthy of a day trip, take a water taxi from North Eleuthera over to Harbour Island. Once there you can rent golf right on the dock to explore the island. We had a lovely, but expensive, lunch at Sip Sip.

Commenting area

  1. What a lovely house you rented. Those beaches also look gorgeous – I could see our family literally living on the beach the whole time!

    • missmagpie March 7, 2014 at 9:00 am · · Reply

      The beaches were incredible. One right after the next. Eleuthera is 110 miles long and on one side you have the Atlantic Ocean and the other the Caribbean. You really get different experience when you travel around. The sand is like nothing I have experienced. I don’t particularly like to snorkel like my the rest of my family, but I didn’t need to. The water is so clear, you can see fish, turtles and even sting-ray swimming by!

  2. WOW! I think I would have a hard time ever leaving the house + beach. That’s all I would need for days! Gorgeous!

    • missmagpie March 7, 2014 at 9:05 pm · · Reply

      Agreed, the house was beautiful! But it wasn’t on the beach, rather high on top of a hill, just a short drive to the ocean. It “forced” us to leave every day.

  3. We love love love the Bahamas!!! So peaceful and quiet and yes, that water is spectacular. You just have to watch out for the strong sun!
    What a perfect vacation for you all…

    • missmagpie March 7, 2014 at 9:10 pm · · Reply

      Yes, that sun is strong. After years of looking, we finally found a sunscreen that keeps our family protected: Goddess Garden Sunny Body Natural Sunscreen SPF 30 (it even comes in travel size and is all natural) http://amzn.to/1cCOwfx

  4. That rental house is gorgeous! We are currently renting a holiday home in New Zealand, and looking at your beautiful beach images reminded me of our holiday here. Although the water is not quite as turquoise here as it is in Eleuthera!

  5. This is a great piece. What a lovely property, too. I really liked the tips you gave. Looks like an expensive island to visit over all, but yet your lodging made it more affordable.

  6. Wow – looks amazing and the accommodation style would suit me too. The Bahamas (or anywhere in that region) seems so exotic to me coming from down here in Australia. One day I really want to explore the Caribbean properly!

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>